Among the most award-winning breweries on the East Coast, Starr Hill has be honored for its quality beers throughout its history with 18 medals at the Great American Beer Festival, 3 awards at the World Beer Cup, and a first place win at the Great British Beer Festival, along with 10 medals from the Virginia Brewers Cup.

The Love Wheat Beer
2008 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2016 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Jomo Vienna-Style Lager
2003 Bronze Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2004 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2005 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2011 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2013 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)
2015 Bronze Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)
2016 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Double Platinum Imperial India Pale Ale
2012 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Sublime Citrus Wit
2016 Gold Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

King of Hop Imperial India Pale Ale
2014 Gold Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Whiter Shade White India Pale Ale
2014 Gold Award (World Beer Cup)
2014 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Vernal Equinox English India Pale Ale
2016 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival – Pro-Am Category)

Monticello Reserve Ale
2011 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival)

Dark Starr Dry Irish Stout
1999 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2000 Bronze Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2001 Bronze Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2005 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2008 Silver Award (World Beer Cup)
2009 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)

Starr Hill Amber Ale
2001 Bronze Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2008 Bronze Award (World Beer Cup)
2005 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival)

Starr Hill Pale Ale
2003 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)
2004 Gold Medal (Great American Beer Festival)

Smoke Out German Smoke Beer
2008 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival – Pro-Am Category)
2011 Silver Medal (Great American Beer Festival)

Festie Oktoberfest Lager
2012 Bronze Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Bourbon Barrel Cryptical Stout (Cask)
2013 Michael Jackson Award (Great British Beer Festival)

Bourbon Barrel Bandstand Barleywine
2014 Silver Medal (Virginia Craft Brewers Cup)

Soul Shine Belgian-Style Pale Ale
2014 Bronze Medal (United States Open Beer Championship)